Contested will or family dispute: use a solicitor.
Someone is challenging the will. A beneficiary is threatening legal action. Siblings disagree on the division of the estate. Or a child left out of the will is considering a Section 117 application. This is outside the scope of DIY probate and needs a solicitor immediately.
What contested probate actually means.
A probate application becomes contested when someone formally challenges the will, the distribution, or the administrator's appointment. This is typically done by lodging a caveat at the Probate Office, which prevents the Grant issuing until the challenge is resolved. Caveats can be lodged by anyone with a potential interest. a disappointed child under Section 117, a disinherited spouse asserting the legal right share under Section 111, or a disappointed sibling challenging the will's validity on capacity grounds.
Once contested, the matter is outside DIY scope. You need a solicitor specialising in contentious probate, not just a general practitioner. The stakes include legal fees from both sides, potential costs orders, and months or years of delay. Most disputes settle without going to full hearing, but the negotiation needs professional handling.
What to do if you suspect a challenge.
Engage a contentious-probate solicitor before applying
If you know a challenge is likely, do not lodge without legal advice. A solicitor will review the will's validity, the testator's capacity at execution, and the likely grounds of challenge. They will also prepare your response strategy.
Check the caveat register at the Probate Office
Before you lodge, your solicitor will check whether a caveat has already been entered. If it has, your application will be blocked until the caveat is withdrawn or the court rules on it.
Address the Section 117 six-month deadline
A child applying under Section 117 must do so within six months of the Grant of Probate. If the application is outside this window, it is generally statute-barred. The time clock matters. do not delay professional advice if a challenge is anticipated.
Consider mediation before litigation
Irish probate disputes increasingly settle through mediation. A solicitor will advise on whether mediation is appropriate and arrange it. Mediation costs €2,000-€5,000; litigation costs €20,000+.
Three mistakes in contested probate.
Trying to negotiate without legal advice. Informal family negotiations can bind you to terms you later regret. Anything agreed in writing can be argued as a binding compromise. Have a solicitor present for any substantive discussion.
Distributing before the dispute is resolved. Early distribution when a challenge is anticipated exposes the executor to personal liability. If the court later finds the will invalid and orders different distribution, the executor is liable for the shortfall.
Assuming a caveat means the will is invalid. Caveats are easy to lodge and frequently tactical. Many are withdrawn within weeks when the basis for challenge is properly tested. Do not panic. take advice.
This is not a ProbatePack case.
Contested estates need contentious-probate solicitors and possibly barristers. Our packs do not apply. If you have arrived here because you suspect a challenge, our honest recommendation is to close this tab and phone a specialist firm today.
Solicitor directly
Contested probate needs contentious-probate specialists. Fees scale with dispute severity. Many settle through mediation.
See the packReadiness Check
Only useful as a briefing document for your solicitor if the dispute risk is speculative rather than active.
See alternative